10 Favorite Broadway Shows You Can’t Miss in NYC
If you’re planning a trip to New York City, one thing you absolutely have to do is catch a Broadway show. Whether you’re a theater nerd, a casual fan, or just in it for the dazzling sets and catchy tunes, Broadway has something for everyone. I’ve seen a lot of shows over the years, and narrowing down my favorites wasn’t easy—but here are my top 10 Broadway shows you absolutely have to see. Trust me, these are the ones worth grabbing those good seats for.
Wicked – A Spellbinding Classic
“Wicked” is the Broadway powerhouse that tells the untold story of the witches of Oz, and honestly, it never gets old. From the gravity-defying anthem “Defying Gravity” to the lush green sets of Emerald City, this show is magical in every sense. If you’re searching for Broadway musicals with strong female leads and unforgettable songs, this one tops the list.
Photo Credit: Broadway.com
Moulin Rouge! The Musical – Pure Glam and Glitz
If you’re into lavish sets, pop music mashups, and all the drama of Parisian nightlife, “Moulin Rouge! The Musical” is your jam. This show is so fun with songs by Lady Gaga, Katy Perry, and Beyoncé. It’s a full-on sensory overload—in the best way possible.
Photo Credit: Broadway.com
& Juliet – Shakespeare Meets Pop Hits
“& Juliet” is one of the most fun shows on Broadway right now, and it’s a must-see if you love high-energy performances and killer soundtracks. Think: a reimagined Romeo and Juliet story told through the hits of Max Martin (yes, the genius behind Britney Spears and Backstreet Boys). It’s fun, empowering, and totally binge-worthy for pop music lovers.
Photo Credit: Broadway.com
The Great Gatsby – A Jazz Age Revival
The newest take on “The Great Gatsby” on Broadway brings F. Scott Fitzgerald’s iconic novel to life with a lush score and a dazzling 1920s aesthetic. If you’re into period dramas, vintage glamour, and American classics, this is a must-see. Plus, the costumes and sets are drop-dead gorgeous.
Photo Credit: Broadway.com
Chicago – All That Jazz
“Chicago” is the longest-running American musical for a reason. Sexy, smart, and endlessly stylish, this show is a masterclass in musical theater. The choreography and razor-sharp satire on fame and justice make it a classic that still feels incredibly modern.
Photo Credit: Broadway.com
The Book of Mormon – Outrageously Funny
If you’re into edgy humor and clever satire, “The Book of Mormon” is the funniest Broadway show you’ll ever see. From the creators of “South Park,” this musical doesn’t pull punches—but it also has a surprising amount of heart. It’s not for the easily offended, but it’s definitely for those who love to laugh.
Photo Credit: Broadway.com
Six – Queens With Killer Vocals
“Six” is like a pop concert-meets-history class, and it’s one of the most empowering musicals I’ve ever seen. Each of Henry VIII’s wives gets her moment to shine in a show packed with fierce vocals, glittering costumes, and girl power. Short and sweet (just 80 minutes!), this is the perfect pick for a night when you want to rock out.
Photo Credit: Broadway.com
The Lion King – A Visual Masterpiece
Disney’s “The Lion King” is the definition of Broadway spectacle. The opening scene alone—“Circle of Life”—gives me goosebumps every single time. With its stunning puppetry, vibrant costumes, and iconic music by Elton John, it’s perfect for families and nostalgic millennials alike. Plus, it’s one of the best Broadway shows for first-time visitors to NYC.
Photo Credit: Broadway.com
Mamma Mia! – A Feel-Good Escape
Is it even legal to have a Broadway favorites list without “Mamma Mia!” on it? This ABBA-fueled romp is feel-good theater at its finest. Set on a sun-soaked Greek island, it’s the perfect escape from NYC’s chaos. Whether you’re a diehard fan or seeing it for the first time, it’s guaranteed to have you dancing in your seat. It is coming back to Broadway for a short period of time so don’t miss it.
Photo Credit: Broadway.com
The Outsiders – Gritty and Powerful
“The Outsiders” is a raw, emotional adaptation of the classic S.E. Hinton novel, and it brings a whole new depth to the story of Ponyboy and the Greasers. With a rock-inspired score and powerful performances, it’s one of the most unique Broadway shows this season. If you’re into stories that hit hard and stay with you, this one’s for you.
Photo Credit: Broadway.com
Whether you’re visiting New York City for the first time or you’re a seasoned theatergoer, these 10 Broadway shows are some of the absolute best. From iconic musicals to bold new hits, there’s no shortage of stage magic in the Big Apple.
One more thing… if you love Broadway, check out the Museum of Broadway. It is a fun museum filled with costumes, props, and sets. Check out my full review HERE.
Planning your Broadway bucket list? Which one are you dying to see first?